DIETARY CONCEPTS
By
Lawrence Wilson, MD
©
December 2009, The Center For Development
Nutrition theories abound.
Each theory helps some people, so books are written extolling this diet
and that approach. As a physician
who specializes in this area, I have worked with over 35,000 clients. Some have followed different systems
before I worked with them, and I always ask for their feedback. I also experimented with a number of
the ideas, if not all of the ones described below. This is a report on my observations of what works and,
when I can figure it out, why they work or do not work as well as claimed.
The
article is divided into dietetic and medical diet concepts, general popular
concepts and metabolic typing concepts.
These are not all that are available, but they represent a good sampling
of those that are most current today.
DIETETIC AND MEDICAL CLASSIFICATIONS OF FOODS
AND NUTRIENTS, AND DIETARY CONCEPTS
THE FOUR FOOD GROUPS
This is an older
dietetic concept suggesting that one needs to eat from the meats, grains,
vegetables and diary groups of foods.
I do not find this concept useful, as it says nothing about quality. Nor does it take into account
individual differences, food allergies, yin and yang and many other
distinctions in the foods we eat.
Even the
federal government and the dietitians who came up with this concept have
largely abandoned it. Having said
this, it is not a false concept.
It simply needs updating because of the huge variation in quality in our
foods today.
THE FOOD PYRAMID
The food pyramid is
a newer dietetic concept that has replaced the four food groups in government
food programs. The base of the
diet pyramid is the grains, with a smaller amount of vegetables, with an even
smaller amount of proteins and at the top, the smallest amount of fats.
This
dietetic concept is incorrect, in my view. Vegetables should be at the top of the pyramid, with
proteins next, and either fats and oils next or perhaps complex carbohydrates
only. Also quality of the food is
not emphasized enough. Recently,
some changes were made to the food pyramid to exclude trans fatty acids and
refined sugars, but many shortcomings remain.
RECOMMENDED DAILY ALLOWANCES (RDA) OR MINIMUM
DAILY REQUIREMENTS (MDR)
These two similar
dietetic concepts assert that certain groups need a set amount of each nutrient
in order to be healthy. This idea
is very inaccurate and not worth much, in my view, because individual needs vary
too much. They depend on oneÕs
age, weight, height, lifestyle, illnesses, metabolic type and much more. The idea is helpful in one regard. This is to bring to peopleÕs attention
that they are not even getting the minimum required daily amount of many
nutrients such as calcium and vitamin A.
This is sad to have to say, but many, many people, especially teens, for
example, do not even meet the RDA levels of these and other nutrients.
Dr.
Weston Price, DDS, studied healthy tribes around the world. He wrote Nutrition and Physical Degeneration. He found that all the healthiest tribes
obtained 4-10 times the recommended daily allowance of the major vitamins and
minerals than American obtain. I
do not agree with all of Dr. PriceÕs recommendations, as they are 100 years old
and the state of the world has changed a lot. For example, it is simply not safe to eat raw food today
very much due to concerns with parasite, in particular. However, overall, Dr. Price was a very
wise physician and researcher.
Thus one must question the adequacy of the recommended daily allowances.
The RDAs and MDRs are far too low, in my view, as they are based on
averages of ÒhealthyÓ people, many of whom are getting ready to be diagnosed
with cancer or diabetes. So I do
not make use this concept.
OTHER DIET CONCEPTS AND SYSTEMS
ORTHOMOLECULAR NUTRITION
This term was coined
by Nobel prize winner, Dr. Linus Pauling. It asserts that one must obtain
the correct amount of a nutrient that each individual needs, and not just
some average or set amount. Drs.
Pauling, Hoffer, Williams and others found that some
people needed 1000 times the amount of vitamin B or C, for example, than other
people.
Reasons for the wide
variation could include difficulty absorbing nutrients, metabolic imbalances,
genetic or metabolic types, the presence of illness, toxic chemicals, stressful
lifestyles or other situations that use up more nutrients.
The orthomolecular
concept is a great improvement over the one-size-fits-all idea of recommended
daily allowances or minimum daily requirements. It recognizes biochemical individuality and the importance
of one's lifestyle, digestion, stress level and other factors that influence
biochemistry and nutrition.
Although the concept
is excellent, it does not in itself help one determine nutritional needs. This leads us to a number of
nutritional systems that can help determine individual needs based on various
concepts, tests or other assessment methodologies.
THE ATKINS, ZONE AND PRITIKIN
APPROACHES
The Atkins Diet. Dr. Robert Atkins was a cardiologist
who popularized a high-fat, low carbohydrate diet. While heavily criticized by the medical and dietetic
community, recent studies have confirmed some of his ideas. He was, in fact, an excellent doctor,
based on the testimony of many people I trust. Extraordinary book sales also bear testimony to the value of
the diet, which turns the food pyramid on its head.
The Atkins diet, as
it was called, emphasized high fats and oils, very low carbohydrates and some
vegetables as the basis of the diet.
Fruit was also excluded for the most part, as are all sugars. The strict version of his diet was ketogenic, which means it caused the body to begin to burn
some of its proteins for energy,
which is helpful for a few people and definitely causes weight loss and other
benefits, especially for those who are hypoglycemic and some diabetics.
I find the Atkins
type of diet very useful for fast oxidizers who require more fats and fewer
carbohydrates. I do not find it
useful for everyone, and I do not agree with all the recommendations, which
include some lower quality foods.
However, I will recommend an Atkins cookbook to some fast oxidizers who
need to reduce the carbohydrates in their diets.
The Zone diet, based on a book by Barry Sears, is similar to Atkins in that it
is a medium to higher-fat diet. It
is a more balanced approach than Atkins and is useful , therefore, for a larger
number of people. It is, however,
not very specific and so I do not use the book or the concept very much at all.
Pritikin Diet. This is a very low-fat approach to
diet. It is quite dangerous, in my
view, and not worth discussing any more than this. The author of it, Nathan Pritikin,
had a large clinic, but dropped dead of a heart attack while jogging, most
likely because his diet was fairly unbalanced.
Since Pritikin, there have been other low-fat approaches, which
all suffer from the same shortcomings as the Pritikin
approach. Fats are very important
for our health and should not be cut out of the diet.
Many other diet
regimens could be discussed. I
pick these as representative of the many diet books available. Some of these are definitely better
than others. They all suffer from
the shortcoming of being a one-size-fits-all concept, however.
MEGAVITAMIN THERAPY
Megavitamin therapy
is the use of doses of isolated nutrients far above daily needs to produce
specific symptomatic effects. For
example, many physicians use high-dose intravenous vitamin C to kill viruses or
bacteria, or as a chelating agent.
Another example is the use of several thousand milligrams daily of
niacin for schizophrenic symptoms or dilation of peripheral vessels.
High-dose
vitamin A may be used to stimulate the immune system and to help fight infections
and cancer. High-dose garlic, taurine or vitamin B6 can help lower blood pressure. Calcium and magnesium in high doses may
relax a person and assist sleep.
This concept uses
isolated nutrients in a drug or pharmacological way. As long as one understands this, it is fine and can be
helpful as symptomatic remedies.
However, that is all it is.
This is not about balance or correction of underlying imbalances.
For this
reason, megavitamin therapy is never my first choice, but may be lifesaving in
an emergency or as a temporary measure.
A VARIETY OF FRESH, NATURAL, ORGANICALLY GROWN,
LOCALLY GROWN FOOD IN SEASON
A concept many
holistic authorities agree on is the nutritional superiority of food that has
not been overly processed, sprayed, refined, overcooked or otherwise
damaged. This I find to be
true as a general principle.
However, this idea can be exaggerated by people who, for instance, will
only eat uncooked food. Here are
exceptions to the idea of all raw, all natural, unprocessed foods:
á Freezing vegetables near the farm can preserve some nutrients that
may be lost in long-distance transport.
Freezing some fish and meats may also preserve them if this is needed
and fresh is not practical.
á A few canned items such as sardines are a good food as they are an
excellent source of calcium and omega-3 fatty acids.
á Some foods, such as grains, must be cooked or they are hard or
impossible to digest. Most other
canned and boxed items are not as good today.
á Fermenting certain foods such as soy and others gets rid of
certain enzyme inhibitors and the phytates they
contain.
á Cooking many foods has advantages that are discussed below.
Locally grown is a fine idea, provided
it is done well. The soil or
farming method may be superior somewhere else, in which case locally grown may
not be best.
Eating
food in season makes good sense, as
it is usually fresher. However,
one's needs may vary and food from elsewhere or out of season may be helpful at
times. Thus, these ideas are great
general principles, but that is all.
In other words, if they are made ÒdogmaÓ one can run into trouble. This is true of most of the concepts we
will review.
Organic or sustainable agriculture is a
concept whose time is coming. It
is only the logical and sensible thing to do to preserve the earth and the food
by not exposing either to highly toxic pesticides, insecticides, fungicides and
more. Many people not realize that
even organic farmers may use a certain amount of toxic chemicals and even toxic
metals in their fertilizers and sprays.
So it is not a foolproof scheme, but a step in the right direction.
RAW FOODS AND JUICES
Raw Diets. A popular theory is that one's food should be eaten raw, or
at least a large percentage of it.
This includes raw salads, fruit, nuts, seeds and soaked grains.. Some people also eat raw meat, milk,
fish and eggs.
I am not
impressed with the results of this type of diet. Here are a few reasons why I do not subscribe to this theory.
1. Cooking kills a
myriad of bacteria and other organisms found in foods, particularly in meats,
eggs, fish and other foods that spoil easily. Today our food comes from all over the world, and especially
from poor nations where food is not clean and those who grow and process the
food are often from an unclean culture.
This accentuates the idea that one must be careful about eating uncooked
food.
2.
Cooking also breaks down fiber in foods, making a lot of nutrients, especially
minerals, more available. Minerals
are not damaged by cooking, contrary to what some say. This is particularly the case with
grains and root vegetables. These
are almost impossible to digest raw if they are very fibrous or very
starchy.
3.
Cooking changes the quality of food.
Heat and salt add yang energy in Chinese medical terminology.
4.
Cooking also concentrates the minerals in many vegetables, allowing one to eat
a lot more of the food. Obtaining
more minerals is often much more important than the loss of a few vitamins and
enzymes due to cooking. No one
advocates overcooking food, by the way, which is definitely damaging.
5. Humans
cannot digest cellulose as well as cows, horses and other grain and root
eaters. This is just a fact and
not to be debated. These animals
also eat huge quantities of raw food, which is necessary because it is less
concentrated. Few people want to
spend their day eating all day.
For all these
reasons, I do not recommend all raw diets and I feel they are quite dangerous,
in fact. The clients I work with
who have followed raw food regimens are, without exception, mineral deficient,
even if they drink vegetable juices, because they are not absorbing their
nutrients well enough.
6. Eating
raw foods is much less grounding than eating cooked, warm food.
Juices
And Blended Foods. Somewhat related to the raw food
concept is the idea of consuming juices and blended ÒsmoothiesÓ and other
blended drinks..
Juices
are definitely helpful to concentrate the minerals, vitamins, enzymes and other
ingredients in foods. About 10-12
ounces of carrot and vegetable juice or green juice daily is excellent.
However,
drinking more juices than this, and drinking fruit juices and smoothies, in
particular, have the following problems:
1) Extremely
yin. This is horribly ungrounding, unhealthy and anti-development, a prime goal
of nutritional balancing science. See
below for more on yin and yang in foods.
2) They
can easily upset the stomach and upset the blood sugar, which is far worse,
3) They
are often contaminated with bacteria and mold if they are not absolutely fresh
and the vegetables very clean, and
4) They
are very watery, which is not helpful for digestion of certain nutrients like
protein. Combining protein powder
in water, therefore, will force the body to move it along without as good
digestion because it dilutes the stomach acid, and
5) Juices
may concentrate anti-nutrients.
The fiber in whole foods serves to buffer the effect of certain toxins
contained in all foods. Juicing
eliminates the fiber and in some cases the toxins are much more easily
absorbed.
6)
Smoothies are usually horrible concoctions of protein powders, isolated
nutrients, fruits, juice and other things that do not mix well in the
stomach. One is often better off
with fewer items and real food such as a whole egg rather than powders and
pills.
Blended Salads and other blended foods and
drinks. These are not good
today, although the idea is okay in theory. Problems are 1) cleanliness, and 2) far too yin. Please avoid blended salads today.
VEGETARIANISM
Vegetarianism is the
avoidance of animal-based foods.
Some vegetarians only avoid red meats. Others avoid all flesh foods. Others avoid eggs, milk and cheese as well. Others avoid even bee products. Finally, fruitarians avoid vegetables,
which usually must be killed to be eaten, preferring to eat only fruit, which
involves no killing. Many
vegetarians are very ill, in my experience. It does not matter if they look good for a while. They usually die young and are not
healthy at all.
Vegetarian
diets are usually deficient in zinc, vitamins A and D, B-complex vitamins,
sulfur-amino acids such as taurine, cysteine and methionine, alpha-lipoic acid, L-carnitine, and
other nutrients that are still being discovered. They are also low in many types of fats that are again still
being discovered as helpful for human health.
Vegetarian
diets are also ungrounding. This has to do with the first chakra and its opening, which
is needed for mental and spiritual development. To read more about this concept, read Keeping Your Feet On The Ground. Please stay away from vegetarian
regimens.
Vegetarian diets are
often part of religious belief systems, non-violent or humanitarian belief
systems. From
a spiritual perspective, I believe animals give their lives to help us live
healthfully, just as we give our lives for our families, our work or other
causes.
I learned
that the Dalai Lama eats meat, though he preaches a vegetarian diet for
others. Though the Dalai Lama is a
fine man, I find this despicable.
Unfortunately, he would be going against his religion to tell people to
kill animals and eat meat, sadly.
This is just a fact about his religion and not a judgment about it.
At times, health
concerns motivate people to become vegetarians, and Dr. Eck noted that some are
Ôobligatory vegetariansÕ, meaning they have trouble digesting meat and dairy products. This is a huge aspect of the appeal of
these diets, unfortunately.
At one time I
embraced vegetarian principles.
This led directly to a health disaster that I am very fortunate to have
recovered from fully. It took
years to recover. I say this not
only as a warning, but to help you know that I have nothing against vegetarian
principles, which are quite wonderful.
The problem is that to get all your nutrients from only non-animal
sources is difficult, if not impossible today. I felt good for a few years, as will many people because
stopping certain foods often gets rid of food reactions that can cause
bloating, gas, and many other symptoms.
However, eventually, deficiencies develop, especially in those with
blood type O, but with most everyone.
A
prominent physician and author I am aware of advocates a vegetarian diet and
seems to do well. What he does not
tell the public is that he must take about $1000.00 per month of supplements to
do this. I consider this totally
dishonest and deceptive, and he is killing people, as far as I am concerned.
Vegetarian
diets are practiced in India and China, but those people usually do it out of
necessity as meat is costly and often not very fresh. Also, the genetics of the Asian people is different, and
they do best with little animal protein of any kind. This is not true of the Caucasian race, basically.
METABOLIC TYPING - A CRITICAL CONCEPT
This is a very
important concept in nutritional balancing science because it works well, in my
experience. It is the concept that
people need different diets based on their body type or metabolic type, as it
is also called.
There are many
systems of metabolic typing. These
range from ancient Chinese acupuncture classification of people based on the
5-element theory, yin and yang, and the macrobiotic classification of yin and
yang, which is different, and the ayurvedic metabolic
classification based on three basic types – pitta,
vatta, and kapha.
There are also many
Western scientific systems such as classifying people by their blood type, or morphogenic types such as adrenal types, thyroid types,
pituitary types, and others. All
seem to have some value.
Nutritional
balancing uses a very simple typing system based on the work of Dr. George
Watson and others in which there are two basic types, fast and slow
oxidizers. This works extremely
well, though no system is perfect.
Two types correspond to the Taoist yin and yang system in many ways, and
it is a simple system to learn and apply.
Fast oxidizers basically need much more fat in their diets, and much
less carbohydrates. Slow oxidizers
do not do well on much fat and feel better on more protein and some complex
carbohydrates. Sweets are
generally bad for both metabolic types, especially fast oxidizers. Slow oxidizers seem more able to handle
some sweets, but they are very damaging for them as well.
MACROBIOTICS APPLIED TO NUTRITIONAL BALANCING
SCIENCE
According
to this diet theory, which is an aspect of ancient Taoist philosophy, all food
can be classified as more yang or more yin. In order to be as healthy as possible, one should balance
the forces of yin and yang in the body by eating foods that are appropriate for
oneself. If one is more yin, for
example, one needs to eat more yang foods. Here are examples of foods, moving from yang to yin:
Yang foods Yin
foods
salt, meats, eggs, poultry,
grains, vegetables, fruits, sweets, drugs
This classification
of foods goes along with the theory of yin and yang. For example, yang is more contracted. Salt, found more in meats, if placed in
a wound, for example, will cause it to contract or close. Yang foods are also more warming and
eaten in the winter months and more in cold climates. Eskimos, for example, live on more meat and no fruit, as it
does not grow much in the arctic.
Those in tropical climates generally need more watery, sugary food to
help counteract the hot climate.
The US army found
out this theory works during World War II when they tried to feed troops in the
tropics and in the arctic the same rations. It did not work and the men became ill. In cold climates, one needs more
warming or yang foods, while in the tropics one needs cooling or more yin
foods.
Grounding and yin and yang. Yang is generally a movement toward the
earth, whereas yin is often, though not always, a movement away from the earth
and toward the sky. Grounding is a
very important concept in nutritional balancing for the development of the
first chakra, and indirectly for all of them. This is another reason to eat a very yang diet, in fact.
Yin
Qualities. Yin is cool, expanded, more sugary,
uncooked, and often broken up or shredded, as occur with blending and juicing
of foods.
Yin foods
include foods that grow on trees, generally, above the earth, whereas yang
foods often grow closer to the earth or under the earth such as roots and
tubers. Yin foods include alcohol
and most all drugs and chemical additives to foods.
Fruits
are very yin, as they are expanded parts of plants and often are sugary and
grow on trees. Nuts and many seeds
are also quite yin. Roasting
almonds makes them much less yin.
Some vegetables such as tomatoes, potatoes, eggplant, peppers and
squashes, among others, are really fruits and are therefore far more yin than
other vegetables and even more yin than some fruits.
Salads
are more yin than cooked vegetables, while juices, smoothies and blended salads
are even more yin because they are uncooked, broken up or blended. For the same reason, grains that are
ground up into flour are more yin than those that are cooked whole.
Potatoes
are an exception, as they grow underground but are very yin. This has to do with their mineral
content, which is another factor.
Minerals such as iron are yang, while minerals such as potassium are
very yin. The slightly more
acid-forming minerals such as iron, phosphorus, sulfur, zinc and others are
more yang. the alkaline-forming
minerals such as copper, manganese, sodium and potassium are more yin.
Another
yin quality of food is its age.
Very fresh food is much more yang.
Older food is much more yin.
Unfortunately, most food today is grown far away and transported for
several days before it is eaten.
This makes it all more yin.
Dried food is more yang, as is frozen food to a degree.
Heating
and cooking food makes it more yang, as heat is a basic yang quality. Fermenting food, however, such as
making milk into yogurt or soybeans into miso or soy
sauce, is not as yang as cooking.
This is important, at times, for those who suggest eating a lot of
fermented foods.
Vitamins
and minerals are also yin in general.
However, water-soluble ones are more yin while glandulars
and fat-soluble nutrients are more yang.
Those that are naturally derived are generally more yang.
Toxic
metals are all yin in nature, as are most toxins. Radiation from nuclear plants and medical x-rays are very
yin. Cell phone radiation, and
that from computers, televisions and other appliances are also very yin. Most people born today are extremely
yin due to the influence of toxins in the environment, especially radiation
which is not seen or felt, but is very important for why we use the healing
methods we suggest today for most people.
A
modified macrobiotic eating system. One can see that
this is a very complex system, but the basics are as stated above. Nutritional balancing uses this system,
which one can read about in a book about macrobiotics only. However, I do not use all the
macrobiotic principles because they were designed for Japanese people thousands
of years ago and things have changed to some degree today. Therefore the system has been changed,
though not much. For example, fish
used to be an excellent food and is highly recommended. Today it is mainly toxic.
Also,
macrobiotics does not take into account the horrible yin conditions on planet
earth today, in my view. In addition,
the diet is restrictive and does not take into account various scientific
observations about iodine, vitamin D, the value of kelp, but not other sea
vegetables and the toxicity of most herbs today. These are the major differences.
Also,
macrobiotics does not recommend much dairy products such as milk, cheese,
yogurt and others. I think this is
mainly because it is somewhat yin and they were not available or not used much
in Japan. However, the Caucasian
race handles them better and they are helpful for many people, so we include
them.
Macrobiotics
is also quite rigid the way some people apply it, and allows too many toxic sea
vegetables, too much rice and not enough blue and yellow corn, and includes too
many beans, which have other problems for Americans, in particular.
Also,
some people believe that women, in particular, should be vegetarians according
to macrobiotics. I feel this is a
terrible mistake and does not take into account the needs of Caucasians and the
needs of our toxic times.
Also, macrobiotics
may recommend herbs that I have found to be toxic today, although perhaps that
was not the case thousands of years ago.
Be very wary of all herbs today.
Also,
today all foods are hybrids and this is another reason certain macrobiotic
ideas such as the virtues of brown rice, must be altered somewhat. Rice is not the same as it was
thousands of years ago when it was not hybridized and it was grown in a totally
different traditional manner.
I use
this modified macrobiotic approach to diet because it works well and need not
be complex. It is the reason to
eat more cooked food, more meat, grains and vegetables, and to basically skip
all fruit, fruit juices, dried fruits, sugars and chemicals.
Why
everyone is more yin today than even 20 years ago when Michio
Kushi taught basic macrobiotics. Yin forces on planet earth are increasing rapidly such as
pollution, radiation poisoning, chemicals in the food, more spoiled and
genetically modified food, more mercury, an extremely yin toxic metal, more
medical drugs everywhere, even in the water supplies and food supplies, more
fluoride and chlorine added to drinking water and much more yin lifestyles.
Yin
lifestyles. These include staying up too late, not
getting enough rest and sleep, using computers and televisions that give off
extremely yin electromagnetic fields, and other yin habits such as too much sex
in some cases, and victim thinking, which is also very yin in nature. All of this is increasing rapidly,
especially among young people who are born yin due to nutritional
imbalances. This is the reason for
certain modifications in the macrobiotic system of diet.
Assessing
Yin And Yang. Yin and yang conditions may be
determined by traditional methods such as acupuncture pulse and tongue
diagnosis, facial features, body shape, skin color and other traditional
measures. However, the nature of
the toxins in modern environments such as cell phone radiation and nuclear
fallout make these ancient methods less applicable today in our
experience. They are still
extremely valuable, but harder to measure accurately.
We find,
however, that hair tissue mineral analysis is helpful for this assessment,
providing the hair is not washed at the laboratory and the ratios below are
followed exactly. Here are the
ratios we use:
1. Fast
oxidation is more yang, while slow oxidation is much more yin. This must be modified by the other
ratios below.
2. A low
sodium/potassium ratio is much more yin, while a high ratio is more yang.
3. A high
calcium/magnesium ratio is more yang, generally, but not always. This is more variable.
4. Higher
levels of toxic metals are more yin.
However, this is variable since most people have their metals well
hidden and they will not show up on any type of tests, often until they begin
to eliminate them during a nutritional balancing program.
5.
Greater age is yin, in general.
Babies are yang, for example, and that is why milk, which is fairly yin,
works for them. As they become
older, they become more yin. Old
people are also much more yin and ill.
6. All illness, particularly cancer,
diabetes and other degenerative conditions, are more yin. However, each illness can be or a more
yin or yang type, depending upon its causes.
7.
Overweight is much more yin in most cases, but not all.
ve this may be due to excessive rigidity and the exclusion of many
excellent foods such as eggs, butter, oils and others.
AYURVEDA
This is an ancient
Indian system of healing that classifies people into metabolic types called doshas. There
are three main ones and many variants, depending on how sophisticated one wants
to get. Ancient methods of
assessment are used, with all the problems of the ancient methods, in my
experience.
I donÕt
use Ayurvedic methods and I do not recommend them, either. Of course, there is much wisdom of the
ancients, but problems as well.
One of the worst is that the herbs that are recommended often contain
toxic metals. This is in part due
to the herbs themselves, and also due to lax regulation of the herbal industry
in India and other nations where they are grown and processed. This can be very dangerous, especially
if one continues to take these herbs over more than a year or so. A good friend was irreparably poisoned
this way and is now living in a nursing home with AlzheimerÕs disease at a
young age. We traced the problem
to his Ayurvedic herbs that are high in toxic metals.
BLOOD TYPE DIETS
This fairly recent
idea states that one should eat according to one's genetic A,B,O
or other blood type. There are
several books such as Eat right For Your Type, by Dr. DÕAdamo,
the man who set up this system.
When I
heard about this idea some 15 years ago, I began asking my patients to tell me
their blood type and I observed results with this diet system. It has merit, but not enough to warrant
all the publicity is has received.
However, it points out, for example, that those with blood type 0 must
eat some meat. I do find that
vegetarians with this blood type often are the most ill, for example. It is useful for this purpose. However, it is an incomplete diet
system and not accurate enough due to all the toxins in the environment today
that cause all manner of food allergies and other problems that the system does
not account for.
ACID-ALKALINE
This popular concept
contends that one must keep one's body is the correct pH range by varying the
diet and often by drinking alkalinizing water. The idea behind this dietary concept has much merit. However, it does not work well at all,
in my opinion, for the following reasons:
1) Assessing tissue pH is
nearly impossible. Hair analysis,
a tissue test, is somewhat helpful, but not very good. Urine, blood, saliva and other tests
are also not measuring the cells themselves and are grossly inaccurate in too
many cases.
2) Alkaline water is
extremely dangerous, in my experience.
It is fine for a few months and will cause positive changes because
everyone is acidic today. However,
it is a shortcut method and platinum plates are used in the machines that
eventually poison the person very badly.
Please stay far away from alkaline water machines, at least all the ones
I have seen such as Kagen and others.
3) To truly alkalinize the
body, one must eat a lot of cooked vegetables to replenish the alkaline reserve
minerals, remove yin toxic metals and chemicals that are yin, balance the
oxidation rate and so on. This is
done in nutritional balancing science very well, but not in most other healing
systems.
OXIDATION TYPES
Dr. George Watson
first coined the term the oxidation types in his 1972 book, Nutrition and
Your Mind. He noticed that
most people could be classified into one of two groups based on their responses
to odor tests. He found that one
group had slightly more acid blood and felt better on some foods than others.
He theorized that
fast oxidizers burned fat better, and benefited from a diet low in
carbohydrates and higher in fat and high-purine
proteins. Slow oxidizers burn
carbohydrates better, and benefit from a diet higher in carbohydrates and low-purine proteins.
Physicians use questionnaires, blood tests, hair tests or other methods
to assess the oxidation rate.
I find this concept
useful, and closely related to the sympathetic/parasympathetic idea put forth
by Dr. Melvin Page and others who have worked on this concept. However, I use the hair tissue mineral
analysis to assess the oxidation type, by the measurements figured out by Dr.
Paul C. Eck of Phoenix, Arizona. I
was his pupil for about 14 years and have written extensively about his
research, which I consider primarily as intuitive and empirical research.
This
means he did not sit with rats or mice, or even with that many human
subjects. Instead, he was a
clinician who reviewed many texts on minerals, in particular, and observed the
effects of various foods, supplements, herbs and other products on hair tissue
mineral tests of over half a million patients, to derive his normal values and
key ratios that he used to assess sympathetic and parasympathetic states as
well as oxidation types. This is
the work I do to this day and I have been most pleased with the results. I also teach this work to anyone who
wants to learn it.
The
oxidation types are discussed in other articles on this website, such as by clicking on Fast, Slow And Mixed Oxidation.
ETHERIC NUTRITION
This is a concept
few have heard of. It states that
certain foods, herbs and other substances help develop the etheric
body, a subtle body that surrounds the physical body and is associated with
health and long life.
Foods
that are most helpful for this include meat, eggs, poultry, fish, root
vegetables, corn, rice and certain herbs.
Foods that are least helpful include fruits, beans, seeds, nuts, sugar
and refined foods of many kinds.
Toxic foods are also discouraged such as aspartame or Nutrasweet, MSG, pesticides and the thousands of other
toxic chemicals in the food supply today.
Other foods that are not helpful are those that are too yin, such as the
nightshade vegetables (potato, tomato, eggplant, peppers and others), too much
fruit and excessive juice, salads in general, alcohol, drugs of all kinds and
many others as well.
For more
information about this important dietary system that is very close to the
macrobiotic concept above, click on the article entitled Etheric
Development And Your Diet.
Home * Hair
Analysis * Saunas * Books * Articles
Detoxification Protocols * Courses * About Dr.
Wilson